Queen Kytha wrote:
sure some things should have an actual explanation, i.e. nether portals, the ender dragon, forced breeding tanks of villagers, but i dont think enchanting is a big enough of a deal that we have to limit what people want to do with it, especially concerning the fact that while we could vote on it now and come to a tentative compromise, what about future people who might have great creative ideas for how their enchanting works but is then limited by this prior vote and they have to either conform or describe their process are mere myth
People's lore is already limited by what we have defined. For example, we have limited what species are allowed in our lore and what the history of our world is like. I would argue that our lore is even more creative and interesting when it builds upon and ties into community consensus.